Stop Hiring, Start Finding: The Right People for Growth

Artisan, the AI startup known for its provocative “Stop Hiring Humans” campaign, ironically understands a fundamental truth: scaling requires a stellar team. While they’re building AI employees for roles in sales and customer engagement, co-founder and CEO Jaspar Carmichael-Jack emphasizes that assembling the right team remains paramount. In a recent episode of Build Mode, Carmichael-Jack shared candidly about the early days of Artisan, the costly hiring mistakes they made, and the lessons learned that ultimately saved the company. This article delves into those insights, offering actionable advice for founders navigating the challenging landscape of early-stage hiring. The reality is, even with advancements in artificial intelligence, human capital remains the core engine of growth for any organization.

The High Cost of Hiring Mistakes

Making poor hiring decisions, or filling positions prematurely, isn’t just a minor setback – it’s a compounding error. These mistakes drain resources, erode team morale, and create execution bottlenecks that can be fatal for a scaling startup. As Carmichael-Jack puts it, “I’ve made a lot of hiring mistakes — like, a lot within every single role.” Artisan reportedly went through over 100 hires to arrive at their current core team of 40, highlighting the iterative and often painful process of finding the right fit.

Overhiring: The Illusion of Speed

A common pitfall for ambitious founders is the belief that simply adding headcount will accelerate growth. Carmichael-Jack discovered the opposite. “I thought that we would scale faster if I hired all these roles and built this huge team, but it actually makes it more difficult to scale,” he explains. Managing a larger team introduces complexity, communication challenges, and the risk of misalignment.

Key Takeaway: In the early stages, prioritize focused execution over rapid expansion. Only hire when existing team members are demonstrably overloaded and unable to effectively handle the workload. A lean, highly motivated team is far more effective than a bloated one.

Beyond the Resume: The “Logo Shopping” Trap

An impressive CV boasting experience at prominent tech companies doesn’t guarantee a successful startup employee. The skills honed in large, well-resourced organizations often don’t translate to the fast-paced, resource-constrained environment of a startup.

Focus on:

• Experience: Look for candidates with a proven track record of delivering results, not just holding prestigious titles.
• Passion: Seek individuals genuinely excited about your mission and willing to go the extra mile.
• Adaptability: Prioritize candidates who demonstrate flexibility, resourcefulness, and a willingness to learn.

Carmichael-Jack emphasizes that passion and experience often outweigh the allure of big-name logos on a resume. A candidate who is genuinely invested in your vision is far more likely to thrive than someone simply seeking a paycheck.

The Goldilocks Zone: Hiring the Right Level of Seniority

Finding the right balance in seniority is crucial. Hiring someone too senior can be problematic. Experienced professionals may struggle to adapt to the ambiguity and lack of structure inherent in an early-stage startup. They might expect established processes and clear hierarchies that simply don’t exist yet.

Conversely, hiring someone too junior can leave you with a skills gap. A less experienced hire may lack the strategic thinking and problem-solving abilities needed to scale their function effectively.

Finding the Sweet Spot: Look for candidates with 3-5 years of relevant experience – enough to demonstrate competence, but not so much that they’re overqualified or resistant to the startup lifestyle. Individuals who are eager to learn and grow are often the best fit.

Speed vs. Thoroughness: The Hiring Paradox

The pressure to fill critical roles quickly can lead to rushed hiring decisions. However, Carmichael-Jack warns against sacrificing thoroughness for speed. “Early on, we were way too slow. So we would sit on a decision for weeks or months and not really do anything and try and help them a bit, but not really, and just float around. And it never works out when you do that,” he recalls.

The Solution: Implement a structured hiring process that includes multiple interviews, skills assessments, and reference checks. Don’t be afraid to take your time and ask tough questions.

However, equally important is decisive action when a candidate isn’t a good fit. “You can tell when someone’s not working out in a role, and usually they know as well,” Carmichael-Jack observes. Prolonging a bad hire is detrimental to both the individual and the team.

The Importance of a Strong Culture Fit

Beyond skills and experience, cultural alignment is paramount. A candidate who doesn’t share your company’s values or work ethic can disrupt team dynamics and undermine morale.

Assess Culture Fit By:

• Behavioral Interviews: Ask questions that reveal how candidates have handled challenging situations in the past.
• Team Interviews: Involve existing team members in the interview process to gauge compatibility.
• Values Alignment: Clearly articulate your company’s core values and assess whether candidates resonate with them.

From Hiring to Finding: A Shift in Mindset

Carmichael-Jack’s experiences at Artisan underscore a critical point: hiring isn’t merely an operational task; it’s a strategic imperative. The wrong hire can derail progress, damage culture, and complicate future recruitment efforts. The right hires, however, create a virtuous cycle of growth and innovation.

Ultimately, even a company dedicated to replacing humans with AI recognizes the enduring importance of human capital. As Carmichael-Jack concludes, “You can’t scale a company without humans — they just have to be the right humans.” The key is to shift from simply “hiring” to actively “finding” individuals who are not only skilled but also passionate, adaptable, and aligned with your company’s vision.

Stay Informed and Inspired

Subscribe to Build Mode on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or your preferred podcast platform. Watch the full video interviews on YouTube.

Apply to Startup Battlefield: GearTech is seeking early-stage companies with a Minimum Viable Product (MVP). Nominate a founder (or yourself) and mention you heard about Startup Battlefield from the Build Mode podcast. Apply here.

GearTech Disrupt 2026: Join us in San Francisco from October 13-15 for GearTech Disrupt, where the Startup Battlefield 200 will take center stage. Network with thousands of founders, VCs, and tech enthusiasts. Grab your tickets now!

San Francisco, CA | October 13-15, 2026

REGISTER NOW