AI Toys Ban? California Considers Four-Year Chatbot Block for Kids
The burgeoning field of Artificial Intelligence (AI) is rapidly infiltrating all aspects of modern life, and the toy industry is no exception. However, a growing wave of concern regarding the safety and developmental impact of AI-powered toys, particularly those featuring chatbots, is prompting legislative action. California Senator Steve Padilla recently introduced Senate Bill 287 (SB 287), a groundbreaking proposal that could impose a four-year ban on the sale and manufacture of toys with AI chatbot capabilities for individuals under 18. This move aims to provide crucial time for safety regulators to develop comprehensive regulations and safeguards to protect children from potentially “dangerous AI interactions.” The debate surrounding AI toys and child safety is intensifying, and California’s potential ban could set a national precedent.
The Push for a Pause: Why California is Considering a Ban
Senator Padilla’s rationale behind SB 287 stems from a deep concern about the current lack of robust safety measures surrounding AI technology, especially when it comes to its use with vulnerable populations like children. He argues that while AI holds immense potential, its rapid development is outpacing the ability of regulators to establish appropriate guidelines. “Chatbots and other AI tools may become integral parts of our lives in the future, but the dangers they pose now require us to take bold action to protect our children,” Senator Padilla stated. “Our safety regulations around this kind of technology are in their infancy and will need to grow as exponentially as the capabilities of this technology do. Pausing the sale of these chatbot-integrated toys allows us time to craft the appropriate safety guidelines and framework for these toys to follow.”
This legislation isn’t occurring in a vacuum. It follows a recent executive order from President Trump directing federal agencies to challenge state AI laws – although this order includes an explicit exception for laws pertaining to child safety. More importantly, several deeply troubling incidents involving AI, chatbots, and children have galvanized lawmakers to address the issue proactively.
Recent Incidents Fueling the Debate
Over the past year, a series of lawsuits filed by families who tragically lost children to suicide after prolonged interactions with chatbots have brought the potential harms of unregulated AI into sharp focus. These cases highlight the vulnerability of young minds and the potential for AI to exacerbate existing mental health challenges. Padilla also co-authored California’s recently passed SB 243, demonstrating a commitment to child safety in the digital realm. SB 243 mandates that chatbot operators implement safeguards to protect children and vulnerable users from harmful content and interactions.
Even before these tragic events, concerns were raised about the content and biases embedded within AI-powered toys. In November 2025, the PIRG Education Fund issued a warning about toys like Kumma, a chatbot-equipped plush bear, which could be easily prompted to discuss inappropriate topics such as matches, knives, and sexual content. Further investigation by NBC News revealed that Miiloo, marketed as an “AI toy for kids” by Chinese company Miriat, occasionally exhibited programming that appeared to reflect Chinese Communist Party values. This raises questions about data privacy, ideological influence, and the potential for manipulation.
The OpenAI & Mattel Delay: A Sign of Caution?
The planned collaboration between OpenAI and Barbie-maker Mattel to release an “AI-powered product” in 2025 was unexpectedly delayed. Neither company has publicly explained the reason for the postponement, leaving industry observers to speculate. This delay could be interpreted as a sign of caution, suggesting that the companies are reassessing the risks and challenges associated with integrating AI into children’s toys. Whether they will proceed with a launch in 2026 remains uncertain.
What Does This Mean for the Future of AI Toys?
The potential ban in California, if enacted, would have significant ramifications for the AI toy market. It could stifle innovation in the short term, but it could also force developers to prioritize safety and ethical considerations. Here’s a breakdown of potential impacts:
- Increased Regulatory Scrutiny: The California proposal is likely to spur other states to consider similar legislation, leading to a more unified and comprehensive regulatory framework for AI toys nationwide.
- Shift in Development Focus: Toy manufacturers may need to invest more heavily in developing robust safety protocols, content filtering mechanisms, and age-appropriate AI models.
- Emphasis on Transparency: Consumers will likely demand greater transparency regarding the data collection practices and algorithms used in AI-powered toys.
- Potential for Innovation in Safe AI: The ban could encourage the development of AI technologies specifically designed for children that prioritize safety and educational value.
The Role of AI Safety Organizations
Organizations like the Partnership on AI and the AI Now Institute are playing a crucial role in advocating for responsible AI development and deployment. They are conducting research, developing best practices, and engaging with policymakers to ensure that AI benefits society as a whole. These organizations are likely to be instrumental in shaping the regulations that will govern the AI toy industry.
Beyond California: The Global Conversation on AI and Children
The debate surrounding AI toys isn’t limited to California. Governments and organizations around the world are grappling with the ethical and safety implications of AI for children. The European Union is considering regulations under the AI Act that would impose strict requirements on AI systems used in toys and other products intended for children. The United Kingdom’s Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) has also issued guidance on the use of AI in education and children’s products.
According to a recent report by Statista, the global AI in toys market is projected to reach $1.8 billion by 2028, growing at a CAGR of 15.2% from 2023 to 2028. This rapid growth underscores the urgency of addressing the safety concerns associated with these products.
“Our Children Cannot Be Used as Lab Rats”
Senator Padilla’s impassioned plea – “Our children cannot be used as lab rats for Big Tech to experiment on” – encapsulates the core concern driving the push for greater regulation. The potential risks associated with unregulated AI toys are simply too great to ignore. While AI offers exciting possibilities for education and entertainment, it’s crucial to prioritize the safety and well-being of children. The debate over SB 287 is a critical step towards ensuring that AI technology is developed and deployed responsibly, protecting the next generation from potential harm.
Stay Informed: GearTech's Coverage of AI Developments
GearTech will continue to provide in-depth coverage of the evolving landscape of AI, including the latest developments in AI safety regulations and the impact on the toy industry. Join us as we explore the challenges and opportunities presented by this transformative technology. Don't miss our upcoming coverage of the GearTech Disrupt 2026 conference, where industry leaders will discuss the future of AI and its implications for various sectors.
GearTech Disrupt 2026
San Francisco | October 13-15, 2026
WAITLIST NOW